How Close Do I Have to Be?
I discovered my daughter six years ago (another story). She lives across the country and grew up in a small Southern U.S. town. The men hunt, the women bake, people marry their kindergarten sweethearts, and everyone celebrates everything together. If no holidays are around the corner, they make new ones. She’s lived and worked there all her life, now with her second husband, and very nearby two children, four grandchildren, and many, many friends.
I grew up in the Northeast to intellectual, classical-music-loving parents who kept to themselves. Even though I’ve lived in Florida for decades, I still consider myself a Northern New Yorker. I watch TV shows set in the city and sigh nostalgically at the street scenes. I’ve come to enjoy Florida, its lush greenery, warmth, and transplanted city neighbors. My husband passed several years ago, and now I live alone, write and work, listen to classical music, binge on predictable Netflix series and remorseful documentaries, and occasionally go out with a friend.
My daughter and I couldn’t have more different existences. We text on birthdays and holidays, email infrequently, call only on birthdays, and each report on our lives in four sentences.
I told two friends about my daughter.
*
My friend Charlotte has a daughter and son and four grandchildren, whom she speaks to weekly, sends frequent gifts to, and visits across the country at least once a month. She said:
Your daughter is your blood! You can’t deny it. It doesn’t matter if she didn’t grow up knowing you. You’re still her mother! You owe her! Admit it—you’re emotionally blocking! You’re all alone, you know. What if you got sick, like my friend Pauline? She went to live with her daughter and they finally reconciled (tearing). You need your daughter and she needs you. Be a grandmother to her kids! Take them places! Buy them things they want!
My friend Jake has three daughters and five grandchildren, whom he rarely sees. He said:
They don’t call me and I don’t call them. We all have our own interests and lives. Why torture everyone at holidays? I have more in common with my dog than my children. Family to me is this: Forget About Me I Love You. My friends, as many people have said, are my chosen family. If there’s nothing in common but blood, does the tie have to be that strong? I don’t think so. You are who you are and have your life and pursuits. You can’t manufacture interest. Be polite, yes, but what’s the point of pretending?
*
So, between Charlotte’s Scylla and Jake’s Charybdis, what do I do? Two role models, one fully involved, the other fully distant. How to navigate so I don’t get emotionally smashed on the rocks of obligation? How guilty should I feel?
I recently learned of the anthology of estrangement No Contact (ed. Jenny Bartoy, Catapult, 2026) and read a review in MUTHA by Asha Dore. Confounding and unsettling questions are raised, and Dore differentiates between essays recounting estrangement resulting from horrid circumstances, such as a father’s sexual abuse, and those in which no traumatic events took place but interest waned and the writer made a conscious “difficult choice to cut off contact.” Dore points out, “The people who approve of estrangement call this choice healthy and crucial. Those who don’t call it toxic, cruel.”

My estrangement may fall into both camps: the trauma to the child of adoption at birth, a later choice to keep distant. Or maybe it’s different for parents like me—birth parents who haven’t had contact or seen their child for all of their adult life. Pregnant in college, I made the choice very early—before she was born—to place her for adoption. In the nursery on the first day, I saw her for only a few minutes and declined to hold her. My overriding desire was to go back to school with no impediments, no encumbrances, no hitches, and concentrate on getting all the degrees. Which I did.
But I always knew it was unfinished, hanging in the background like old Christmas decorations left up until Easter. I knew I had to face it, but with each passing year I told myself I “wasn’t ready.”
And then, a few years ago, through a strange (divinely orchestrated?) set of events, my niece, with whom I’d become close in adulthood, sent me an email titled “Bombshell.” She said that through an ancestry site my daughter had located me and, if I were willing, wanted to connect. My niece very compassionately said too that if I didn’t want to, she would understand and not judge me.
I didn’t know if my daughter would have had such an empathic outlook. Nevertheless, almost relieved at it finally happening, I emailed her. Cheerily, we exchanged details of our lives. But underneath lurked the black questions, which I couldn’t push away: How could I ever explain giving her up? How could I rationalize it? Would she ever forgive me?
After a year, she came to visit with her own two adult children. After all the screams and obligatory hugs (only shoulders touching), they left us alone in a secluded spot in their hotel lounge, and we talked. I attempted to explain, and she interrupted me. “I don’t have any anger. I understand. My parents were wonderful and I’m thankful for my life. I forgive you.” Flabbergasted, I started to cry. Then we hugged a little closer and promised to keep in touch.
At first our emails were quite regular, once every two weeks, and then with more and more time in between. I’ve found myself repeating my news (a new friend or publication, condo construction progress). In each of hers is the latest on her life and the whole tribe—work (she’s an elementary school English teacher), health, gym, second husband, celebrations, her children, their children, other relatives and their children, friends and their children.

Yes, I’ve gained a window into small-town, satisfied life—and in a way I envy it. A simpler life, unencumbered by the pressure to overachieve, although it’s hard to know if my small-town fantasy is true. But what now? Occasionally I’ve floated a few deeper questions (Do you believe in an Inner Voice? What experiences have you had?), but her responses have been monosyllabic.
The emails have gotten more infrequent. When my granddaughter (her daughter) visited recently, we FaceTimed with my daughter, and I apologized for owing her an email. Almost indifferently, she said, “I’m not keeping score.”
No cries of “Yes, please write! I’m eager to hear from you! I want to know what you’re doing!” No smile, even. Maybe she’s at the same impasse of indifference as I am. If I asked, she’d probably answer in a couple of words.
Questions arise: What have I gained by finally knowing her? Do I regret not raising her? Even though many women go to college while parenting, and I applaud them, I don’t think I’d ever have gotten the graduate degrees or written anything, much less books, if I’d been raising a child. Despite my enjoyment of occasional babysitting and play, and the screen depictions of gushing parents’ suffusions of joy, I never wanted a child.
Should I try to manufacture closeness? Seems impossible. And what’s the point? (I think of Jake’s words.) Maybe it’s callous, but I’m relieved. I never wavered from or regretted my decision. Thinking about a child—at any stage—crowds my brain. All I can see is freedom curtailed, autonomy castrated, writing dried up in a pile of baby laundry. Is the “estrangement,” as Dore in No Contact reports, healthy and crucial or toxic and cruel? And for whom?
How much should I force it, pretend? I was always busy with my own life: writing, editing, husband. Can I be satisfied with the intermittent, largely superficial contact with my daughter? Should I try more probing questions, sharing, again? Maybe I didn’t give her a chance. Maybe if I do I’ll find treasure.
The questions keep coming. Should I try to manufacture more closeness and intimacy? What if she responds well? Or am I kidding myself? I must admit (red-faced) I’m really not interested.

Maybe, like my friend Charlotte says, I’m denying the intrinsic “mother” instinct, but I don’t at all regret my decision. Ironically, I’ve become very close to her grown daughter, my granddaughter. She grew up in the same town, married her childhood sweetheart, and often hosts many of the celebrations.
But something is different. Despite cultural differences, we’ve found many common touchpoints and, like me, she’s interested in spiritual exploration and ramifications and exploring deeper meanings of many things. I know she sees me as a “person” and not just a grandmother. (I’m certainly not the doting, gray-haired, flowered dress, incessantly cleaning type.) I feel I can talk with her about anything, and she’s admitted the same. It’s a very satisfying relationship.
I’ve wondered about her relationship with my daughter, her mother. I know she tells my daughter about work and kids. But is there an inevitable distance born of lingering adolescent resentments, values clashes, my granddaughter’s ambitions and her mother’s contented existence? Unless my granddaughter wants to tell me, none of it is my business, and I won’t ask.
I’m grateful for what I have and will continue to enjoy with my granddaughter, sharing my life with her. With my daughter, unless I take the leap and risk more meaningful probing, I’ll keep emailing her—infrequently.
