Published on January 17th, 2014 | by Jennifer Pastiloff



I often think about the choices we make as humans and about how sometimes those choices, seem futile, naïve, masochistic. Un-human even. How sometimes, they lock us into a life we never imagined. You may want to pound your head into the wall (as I have done) upon looking back, say, at the choice to stay the night with an ex-boyfriend, who, when you ask if he can give you a ride to the Philadelphia airport the next morning, says, with a breath full of alcohol from the night before, “I’ll give you a ride to the airport for a hummer.”

The choice as to whether to give him a blowjob in exchange for a ride was simple one.

You go into the bathroom, and in the dark of 5 a.m., call a friend.

She picks you up and you never see the bribing ex-boyfriend ever again.

But that’s not the choice that makes you want to rewrite history. It’s the choice to have been with him in the first place. To have ended up at his friend’s condo in a cul-de-sac, during a snowstorm, looking under a mat for a key that wasn’t there.

-2The choice to stand freezing while he pees on snow then breaks through the window.

The choice to not run right then and there.

That choice.

The choice to stay.

There are some choices like bullets- you dodge them as best you can until one hits you. It feels inevitable – as much as you tried to not get shot, you always knew you’d get hit. The bullet takes you down and when you rise, albeit a bit bloodied, you move through the world like anyone who has been shot would move. Slowly at first. Cautious. Watching over your shoulder for snipers.

My need to save what is unsaveable, to preserve- that’s why I chose to stay in the snowstorm that night with an ex-boyfriend even though the night before he slurred into the phone, drunkenly, “ Shigget Condoms?”

“What is a shigget condom?” I whispered, embarrassed, into the phone.  I was in line at the drugstore getting Sudafed to decongest for my upcoming flight.

“Shigget Condoms?






I had no intention of sleeping with him ever again so I simply got Sudafed, an US Weekly magazine and gum.

I chose, however, to sleep over with him instead of a hotel or a friend’s, as if by staying the night I could go back in time and be fifteen again. There I was, wearing a Champion sweatshirt, clear braces, a leftover tan from the summer. He was my boyfriend, I haven’t yet graduated high school and made the choices that would alter my life in ways that would render me nearly dead.

I wanted that time back.

I had flown into Philadelphia to attend my friend’s wedding. We’d just turned 30 years old, he was getting married and his mother was dying.

I’d borrowed a dress from my aunt, some pantyhose and a black color stick for the gray hairs that had started to sprout. I’m getting old, I thought. I’m getting old and I can’t stop it from happening.

I’d sat in the back of the ceremony touching the black ink I’d put over the sparse grey hairs. It was too dark for my own color brown. The black felt wet and sticky, like dried mucus or mascara left in a drawer for too many years. I’d spit into my hand to try and wipe it off but only ended up with black fingers.

My friend got married and the best I could do was time travel back to an ex-boyfriend I didn’t even like in hopes of preserving the past. It was cold, January cold in New Jersey, and there were still Christmas decorations up in the church. I time traveled back to June of 1993. I was running through the park in Haddonfield with my Walkman hooked to my shorts. I thought if I told myself over and over again as I ran You are a runner You are a runner You are a runner that it would make me one.


I ran for two hours a day. I lost so much weight my hair fell out. I pulled myself back to that park, to the summer before I started college and I stayed there for a while, listening to my mix-tapes I’d made for running. The church and the wedding far off in the future, my friend’s mother does not have cancer. She cleans compulsively and has a wicked sense of humor. She is rooted to the earth without any suggestion otherwise, at least for twelve more years.

I think about the choices we sometimes make, how much is about survival. Will this keep me alive? Will this kill me?  Depending on our mental health, we usually pick the one that keeps us alive, that preserves us.

I’ve always been afraid of disappearing.

I used to look in the mirror compulsively to check to see if I was still there.

And now? Am I still there? Am I still a person in the world? And now?

Have I vanished?

I couldn’t walk by a reflection without peeking. Phew. There I am. Literally anything that could reflect an object was not safe. I would check. Knives, glass, mirrors, windows, bottoms of lipstick tubes.

And there I would always be, standing on a street corner, in the rain. In my car, or at the restaurant, taking an order.

The big mirrors that lined the walls at the restaurant kept me knowing I was alive as I took orders for veggie burgers and chicken pot pies. I would write down the order as I checked out my reflection sideways.

I was a walking dead person. Unless I checked the mirror I would have no proof that I was still there. So I proved it every chance I could get.

I worried that one day I would look into the mirror and nothing would be looking back. That I would have become nothing.

Last night I remembered something a friend send to me, something to the effect of “Mirrors aren’t for reminding yourself who you are. Trust yourself. Mirrors are for checking if you have shit in your teeth.”

So I’d slip back into my past as a way to preserve myself. I know I existed back then. I shall go back and live there.

I’d end up with an ex-boyfriend standing in the snow watching it turn yellow with pee. There. I’ve not disappeared. I can see myself in snow. I can smell piss. I can feel the cold. I am alive.

How much we do to survive. The lengths we will go to not disappear.

I think a lot about what people do to survive in the world and how easy it is to judge them for it.

“She dropped out of such a good school and with such a promising future. She took a job at a restaurant and stayed there for over ten years with that education. She is with an ex-boyfriend that can’t even look her in the eye.”

Survival, all of it.


I remember the first time I went to Rome. I was 20 years old, in the Scholar’s Program at NYU. We were traveling as a group to the Colosseum and had been warned about the pickpockets and gypsies. I watched, astounded as the young women used newspapers and babies as pawns to rob people.

I remember thinking how awful, how clever. How they did what they needed to do- to get by, to survive.

I’d watch day old news make its way to waists. Old weather would cover the quiet action of fingers used to the feel and design of foreign pockets. The way certain fabrics would lend themselves to slipping in, to taking. I’d watch all of this as I gripped my camera case to my body and wrote poems in my head about gypsies in Rome.

There was one I watched for quite some time. After she’d counted all the money she’d gathered, she’d lick her fingers. To taste the money, and for luck, I suppose.

I was fascinated at what she was capable of.

The last time I was in Rome was last summer. I rented an apartment in Trastevere, my favorite part of the city. The old Jewish ghetto.

The apartment owners lived upstairs where they’d bake pizzas and come down to collect any money you owed. I found myself looking through old books previous renters had left. Guide books of Italy, John Grisham novels and other cheap paperbacks. Books in Italian, French, Swedish. My eye kept going back to a small paperback. Patrimony by Philip Roth.

I read Portnoy’s Complaint in one night in Boston while I was visiting my then boyfriend. Philip Roth of Newark, New Jersey. I found it funny that his book, dog-eared no less, was in this rental apartment in Rome. I picked it up, smelled it and stuck it in my bag.

I brought many books with me last summer to Italy and read none of them. I kept reaching in my bag on the airplane to touch Patrimony. To make sure it was still mine.

I stole it from the apartment, which made me feel like those gypsies I used to see stealing from the tourists. I stole a Roth novel.

It too sat unread until recently. I finally picked it up after I found out I was pregnant.

I read it in one sitting. I reread passages and sobbed with the book over my face. I cried for my father, my own Jewishness we’d abandoned after he died, and because my hormones were making me crazy.

After I found out I that my pregnancy was ectopic and after I lost it, I picked the book up again. I searched for which paragraphs had broken me, which sentences sent me to the moon. It was the last line, the whole gist of the book really, the whole of this little book I had pilfered all the way from Italy: you must not forget anything. The last line of the book.

I could never go back, I realized there in the pee-stained snow that night when I was 30. Not only could I never go back, but I would never forget, and they weren’t dependent on one another for survival. I would not have to visit my father’s headstone in the Jewish cemetery every time I was in New Jersey to remember that I was his daughter. I would not have to stay in the thick of those trees back there in that park in 1993, sweat running into my eyes, shivering like a hurt bird. I could emerge from the past, intact. I could stop looking in mirrors to check if I was alive so much because as long as I was opening my eyes each morning I was not gone yet. My feet, one before the other, would hit the floor for the day and as they swung from my bed, that would be proof enough that I had made it one more day without disappearing.

Tags: , , , , , ,

About the Author

Jennifer Pastiloff is the founder of The Manifest-Station blog. Her work has appeared in numerous publications, including, most recently, The Rumpus. She can be found drinking coffee (or wine), reading books, writing or downward-dogging. She leads yoga/writing retreats and workshops around the world. Jen has another writing retreat with author Emily Rapp in October in Vermont. All information at www.jenniferpastiloff.com. She tweets at @jenpastiloff.

16 Responses to JENNIFER PASTILOFF on Disappearing

  1. Beautiful, beautiful ,beautiful. Got my heart.

  2. Alaina says:

    Oh my gosh! Thank you, so much, for this piece…for writing and sharing, and doing it so givingly, bravely, and real. I could cry. I’m in a waiting room and somehow this was exactly what I needed to come back down to earth and feel real and connected myself. I always have to save quotes from you because your relatable, beautiful writing brings me back to life!

  3. Annette says:

    You make me want to write! Beautiful!

  4. George says:

    Watch our world, here comes Jennifer Pastiloff…sheer delight-more please! (no, really-PLEASE! We need your voice!!)

  5. Papa Jack says:

    I love reading your work…almost made me want to write…almost… Love You and who you are

  6. Tamara says:

    So beautiful, So, so real. Everything you write Jennifer, touches me. I am constantly wrenched by the realness of you and your writing. And I agree with the above comments – I think that’s what I feel when I read something you have written, it makes me want to write. (even though, I am not a writer) Also, it always makes me want to hug you – so fair warning, should we ever happen to meet … I will be the crazed woman, probably eyes streaming, much to eager to give you a hug, even though we just met.
    Thank you for sharing this.

  7. Amanda says:

    Too unforgettable to disappear…amazing words.

  8. charlotte thompson says:

    not bad-not bad at all..when i read i become the page…it’s like a movie in front of my eyes..it’s realistic to me..i’m still cold from you standing in the snow and smelling his urine..lol…im looking forward reading more
    of you stuff…:)

  9. Debbie says:


  10. Paulina says:

    Dear Jennifer, Someone once told me that “pain is the touchstone of spiritual growth” – for better or worse, I think this is true. Painful memories also make for authentic, compelling writing like yours. I thoroughly enjoy catching glimpses into your life. I see how you have grown and changed, and how you continue to do so. I look forward to a full-length memoir someday.

  11. Laura says:

    I just discovered Jennifer Pastiloff & am I ever happy about it… This was a beautifully written article that touches everyone that lives life as they do, sometimes regretfully, but still fully… Thanks!

  12. Jt says:

    Excellent. I am here, you are here, we are here – do not disappear!

  13. Skye Leslie says:

    Touched me to tears. I’m at the age now, where, culturally, I’m becoming invisible and reaching back in to the past is the touch stone easiest, it seems at the time, to fortify the belief that although so many seem no longer able to see me – that I am, indeed, here. And yet, too much of my past, is no consolation, having, in order to survive, made choices which let me keep breathing but did not afford a life I really had any interest in. Thank you for your write.

  14. Kay Jay says:

    Thank you for your words. Your piece answered a crucial question of why I am in my current situation right now. Keep sharing your heart. xx

  15. Michelle says:

    I have been waiting for this. Thank you so much.

  16. H.S. Brett says:

    Beautiful, soulful, and inspiring.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

We love comments, feedback and critique but mean or snarky comments will not be published. MUTHA moderates ALL comments, and we're a volunteer org, and that means they can be slow to post--please do not try and repost a comment unless it's been more than several days, we will get to it.

Back to Top ↑